christine~ (eppylover) wrote,

Reading Music vs. Playing By Ear

I'd love to ride-em THIS cowboy!Remember:
Some eppylover -posted pictures pack
Awesome Hovermouseover Power!

The following started out as a comment to a post by layla1188, but as sometimes happens, has evolved into a post to my own LJ.

How did I do it?
Ma started me on piano lessons when I was 5. I finally rebelled and quit when I was 11 ... and most of it's forgotten now, unfortunately. Funny thing is, after 3 or so years of lessons, Mrs Sage had to take Ma aside to tell her that, after all this time, she suddenly realized that unknown to both of them I still could not read a note of music, but was playing the damn piano very acceptably! (I hesitate to say "perfectly" because nobody's perfect, least of all me.)

The reason this was happening was: Mrs Sage would pre-play the piece before she had me try it for the first time. Then when I played it, all I was doing was playing it by ear according to what I heard just previously! What a devil I was.

When she'd play it, I somehow used the printed music notes as "clues" or "prompts" to what I would have to mimic.

My aesthetic, ethereal brand of piano playingWhen Mrs Sage stopped pre-playing the music, my playing went all to hell. I never could learn to read music properly. Piano lessons became misery. Ma was determined that I know how to read the music, since she could never learn by that method, no matter how hard she tried (she was taking lessons right along with me, only a little more advanced).

Shit, all I ever wanted to do, all I ever could do, was to hear the beauty ... not "read" the music like a book or something. My way of thinking tends to be more, I dunno, ethereal or aesthetic and creative or intuitive than rote and literal, detailed or organized. With music, my mind cannot merge the two concepts. Is this a right-brain/left-brain conflict? I dunno.
Play the piano? This is about all I can handle now!

(Don't forget to hover over my pics)

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.